Italian football is experiencing a period of intense tension regarding refereeing and the use of VAR. In recent months, several incidents have sparked controversy and criticism regarding the technical and organizational management of the well-known video control system. The Italian Football Federation, led by President Gabriele Gravina, is evaluating structural changes to modify the refereeing structure and improve the use of technology. Decisions could be made by the next season, with the aim of restoring trust and credibility in a tool that promised to solve problems, rather than create new ones.
Between mistakes, controversies and the desire for change
Recent errors have had a significant impact on public debate. Ramon's failed red card during the Como-Napoli match reignited discussions about the consistency of disciplinary assessments. The Napoli-Inter match, with a controversial penalty, symbolized the difficulties associated with image interpretation and communication between the referee and the VAR room. In both situations, technology did not eliminate the controversy, but rather raised serious doubts about its practical application. The problem lies not only in the technical error, but also in the overall management of procedures.
In a season that sees Inter as a protagonist in football, as well as favourite to win the Scudetto according to the odds on the top Italian league, a game is therefore being played that has little to do with football. All this with the prospect of revolutionizing not only the methodology of using VAR, but also the ranks and positions within the Italian refereeing world. Gianluca Rocchi, current head of the National Referees Commission for Serie A, has in fact come under fire.
Several clubs have highlighted what they consider to be inconsistent management and a use of VAR that is not always considered effective. Rocchi defended the refereeing structure's work, but the number of controversial incidents has fueled (and continues to fuel) the perception of a lack of consistency. The federation is analyzing the situation very carefully, because the league's credibility also depends on the transparency of its decisions.
Possible changes to the refereeing structure
Gabriele Gravina is considering appointing Daniele Orsato, currently the Serie C referee designator, as Serie A referee designator. His international experience represents a valuable asset, but there are some question marks. Some internal evaluations concern his personality, which is considered less inclined to engage openly with clubs and management (a crucial aspect today). Orsato's appointment would mark a significant shift in management, with a more rigorous and centralized approach.
The federation is also exploring technological improvements to make VAR clearer and more functional. The International Football Association Board is considering extending video review to include cases such as decisive second yellow cards, which are currently excluded from the standard protocol. This potential change would allow for intervention on incidents that directly impact the outcome of a match. Another proposal involves introducing "calls" available to teams, as is the case in other sports. Each team could request a review of a controversial action within a limited number of attempts.
Leave a comment (0)